"Infinite Rider" <***@aol.com> wrote in message news:33cd1141-2a03-4165-b6e2-***@glegroupsg2000goo.googlegroups.com...
}I thought "Porpoise Song" was a darned good choice for "Vanilla Sky" as it
fit the section of the movie in which it was used very well. Better than the
original song written for the movie by Paul McCartney, which to me was not
only a little on the ordinary side, but also sounded like a reworking of
"Blackbird" and "Rocky Raccoon." I think Paul received an Academy Award
nomination for his song but it just didn't strike me as being worthy of an
Oscar nod. I always thought "Porpoise Song" was worthy of an Oscar nod but
when it came out, it was still in the day when Hollywood's idea of pop
music. Hollywood's idea of pop music in those days was artists like Frank
Sinatra and songwriters/musicians like Henry Mancini or Burt Bacharach and
Hal David. They still had an aversion to rock-oriented artists and groups.
Right, they would never have considered the Monkees in any case, just as the
RnR hall of Fame won't.
}The title, writing and performing credits started showing up in many of the
rock-oriented movies of the mid-to-late 60s.
Some, but not many IME. It wasn't until the seventies that it became more
regular.
}And only very rarely in other movies. In retrospect, song titles, the
artists performing the songs and the writers who wrote the songs should've
been a given all along. Strangely and maybe totally perverse, there's still
movies to this day where none of the songs, artists and writers (and even
music publishers) are credited but there's credits for the food caterers and
drivers and (where appropriate) school teachers for child actors.
Yes, I find that annoying when I'm trying to find out what a song was.
Happens more in TV shows than movies these days however.
}As much as it cost to make movies these days, those are credits which
should be excluded on the grounds of being nonessential.
I agree.
}But, I suppose those professions have their unions which wield considerable
clout and Hollywood has to credit them.
Yep, it's part of creating a CV/profile in the industry, and would be
written into most contracts these days. Recording credits on CD's these days
are usually far more extensive than they were in the days of vinyl for the
same reason.
}But, wouldn't it have been a sight to have seen older people going into a
record store and asking for "that record by the Monkees" and buying the
record?
Nice fantasy :-)
}I could've just seen the puzzled look on the faces of the store clerks,
wondering why the Monkees were suddenly appealing to an older market. Of
course, as the title wasn't mentioned in the song, the failure to ID the
song in the movie would've made it difficult for anyone to have gone into
the record store and asked about it or bought it.
People often asked their record store about movie soundtracks and songs.
Even if they were in the credits, they often missed those. I would bet money
that few ever did in this case!
Trevor.